Looking for peaceful secluded waterfront cabin

Hello all ,new guy here from southwest Ohio, Wife and I are coming up to stay 4 nights in mid June.wanting to rent a lakefront cabin near Silver lake ,Union Falls but open to suggestions west of there , just wanting a lake with no jets skis ,or a lot of boat traffic Hoping to catch a few fish too ,bass or a pike ,maybe a few panfish for dinner one night .I love this forum ,lots of great info.Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks , Jon